How to Plant in Straw Bales for Growth and a Great Harvest

Planting & growing
Photo by Melinda Myers

After prepping your bales, it’s time to plant your plants in your straw bales and tend to them as they grow. In this last chapter, you’ll learn how to decide whether potting or direct planting is a better fit for your garden, how to keep your plants healthy as they grow, and how to harvest different types of vegetables in a straw bale garden.

How to plant in straw bales

You can plant seeds directly into the bales using seed starting or potting mix, or grow your seeds in pots before planting out the young plants. One great advantage of straw bale gardening is that ordinary garden soil will have long been home to slugs, snails and other bugs, who will jump – or crawl – at the chance of nibbling your baby plants.

Squash seedlingA squash seedling growing in a straw bale. Photo by Scott Sherrill-Mix

As with all growing your own, ensure you don’t plant out any delicate young plants until the risk of frost has passed.

Pot or plant directly?

On the whole, it’s best to plant your seeds directly into the straw bales. This allows the plants to spread their roots out between the stalks and gain a good anchorage to support themselves. If you prefer to plant your seeds in pots, perhaps in a greenhouse or indoors on the window sill, simply make sure they’ve got a good firm root ball before planting into the straw bale as directed below.

Tomato transplantsPhoto by Kurt Morrow

Planting seeds directly into the bales

  1. Either: sprinkle seed starting mix over the bales to a thickness of one or two inches (if you’re watching costs, it’s fine to use ordinary potting mix, providing it doesn’t have any big lumps which could impede germination). Or: using a trowel, dig a hole three inches down into the straw and fill it with compost. This method will save on compost if you’re only planting two or three plants in the bale. Sowing directly in straw balesSome seeds can be sprinkled directly onto the bale. Photo by Melinda Myers
  2. Don’t be tempted to top up with soil from your garden, as it may contain bacteria, weed seeds and even slug or snail eggs.
  3. Sow your seeds as per the instructions on the packet – generally speaking, larger seeds such as cucumber can be pushed into the soil, whilst smaller seeds, such as lettuce, should be sprinkled on the top and watered in (you can sieve growing mix over the top although this is not essential).
  4. Water the seeds with a fine sprinkler head. Or if, like me, you can be a little heavy-handed with the watering, then water the compost before you sow the seeds! As long as they’re kept moist, they will germinate.

Planting out young plants from pots

To plant out from a pot, push a trowel into the bale, twisting it until you have a hole wide enough to fit your plant’s entire root ball. Include all the compost from the pot too. If your plant is small, add extra compost. Essentially, you need to include enough for the roots to become well-established before they spread out into the straw.

Planting in balesPhoto by Ruth Temple

How to maintain your plants for a healthy harvest

Once your plants are settled in to the straw bale garden, you’ll have to perform a few regular tasks to help them grow. Just like in a soil-based garden, they’ll need supports, regular watering, and weeding as they grow.

1. Watering and fertilizing in straw bales

Straw bale gardens require a lot of hydration because straw dries out far more quickly than traditional soil. Depending on your climate, you may need to water as often as once per day, although a simple irrigation system and a timer can cut out this process entirely. A good rule of thumb is to keep watering until water leaks out of the bottom of the bale and to water again when the straw no longer feels wet.

Straw bale wateringPhoto by knitsteel

Generally, you can continue to fertilize your plants with seaweed mixes, compost teas, and other organic fertilizers once every one to two weeks until harvest. Be sure to check the instructions for your specific plant before putting together a fertilizing plan, as some plants may need more or less frequent fertilization than others.

Straw bale fertilizerPhoto by Doug Beckers

2. Weeding

Weeding in a straw bale garden is easier than in a soil garden for two reasons: one, far fewer weeds creep into straw than into soil, and two, the bales are elevated to make weeding less uncomfortable. You can avoid weeds in the first place by separating the bales from the ground with cardboard, newspaper, fabric, or membrane, or by placing the bales on a weed-free surface like concrete. You can also keep the weeds on distance from your bales using a weed eater or cordless string trimmer.

When they do sneak in, though, weed as you would in soil, pulling the plants from as close to the base as you can to make sure their roots come up with the stalk. Be careful not to weaken the bale as you pull. Luckily, it’s much easier to pull weeds from straw than from soil.

3. Pruning and maintenance

Just like in a regular garden, you’ll also want to keep an eye out for any dead or unhealthy-looking leaves and fruits. If you notice a rotting, discolored, or pest-infested fruit on one of your plants, remove it immediately (but carefully). Otherwise, it will drain necessary nutrients that the healthy fruits need to continue growing.

Pruning tomatoesPhoto by Frances

The same goes for leaves—carefully removing any heavily yellowed or shriveled and dried leaves will free up more energy for the healthier ones. This is particularly important for flowers.

4. Utilizing supports

Before you started the growing process, you installed supports for your fruiting plants. As they grow, you’ll need to secure many of their vines and stalks to the supports to keep them growing in the right direction. Use twist-ties, twine, or loosely-looped wire to hold them in place.

Tomato stakesPhoto by Steven Reynolds

Plants like squash, beans, melons, cucumbers, and peas either climb or twine around supports on their own and will usually not need ties to hold them in place long-term. However, ties can be used as-needed to help train the plants to grow in the desired direction.

How to harvest from straw bales

Row of tomato plantsPhoto by Laura Hamilton

After weeks to months of care, you’re finally ready to harvest the fruits of your labor and enjoy the flavors of your hard work.

Harvesting is one of the easiest parts of the gardening process; luckily, it’s virtually the same for soil gardening as it is for straw bale gardening. Fruiting plants and leafy greens will grow at about their normal rate, and the normal signs of ripeness (rich colors and the proper size and firmness) will clue you in that it’s time to pick.

Harvesting root vegetables

Potatoes planted in strawPhoto by Jess

Root vegetables are the only plants that will require a slightly different approach come harvest time. Carrots may be easily dug or pried from the straw, as will turnips and radishes.

Harvesting your potatoes

Potatoes, however, grow a little deeper; to get to the lower levels of potatoes in the bale, you’ll need to cut the bale’s twine. Then, separate the straw into its natural sections or “layers” on either side of the potato plant before pulling it from the straw. Make sure to root through the straw when you’re done, as some of the potatoes may have been dislodged during the process.

How to reuse and recycle your bales as compost

In cooler climates, straw bales may last for two years, although they will be starting to look rather tired. If your bales are still in decent shape (not falling apart), you can safely reuse the ones that grew leafy vegetables and fruiting plants to grow winter veggies in a greenhouse or store them in your shed for the next season.

Use caution with root veggie bales: turnip, carrot, and radish harvests may leave the bales in serviceable condition if you’re careful with them, but the digging necessary to harvest potatoes will leave the straw in those bales too loose for reuse.

Using straw as mulchStraw can be reused as mulch. Photo by peppergrasss

Warmer climates

Gardeners in warmer climates can recycle their bales onto the compost heap at the end of the growing season – which could be Christmas in some places.

Remember the bales are heavy when full of water, so you may wish to allow them to dry out under a tarp before moving them. If you don’t have a compost area, covering them with tarp or old carpet will allow a good amount of breaking down of the straw in situ. You can then fork the straw onto beds to soak their nutrients into the soil.

Try it yourself

Straw balesPhoto by knitsteel

If you love growing your own but don’t have the space or the right soil for a productive vegetable plot, straw bale gardening is definitely worth a try. Beyond the initial two weeks of preparation, you should find yourself with minimal weeding and pests to deal with. Instead you can enjoy growing and harvesting nearly any plant you choose in a container that is entirely natural.

Share your thoughts

  1. Melinda

    I love this great info, easy to read I can’t wait to have my straw garden this year!! Thank you for all the helpful information.

  2. Diane Lutts

    I have been straw bale gardening for 6 or 7 years now. I live in a cooler area of the Pacific Northwest and I now have amazing success with tomatoes and cucumbers. 3 tomato plants give me all I need for eating fresh and canning too!

  3. Michelle

    Oops I just planted my small seedlings yesterday and a few of them were pretty tiny. I didn’t put potting mix in the holes in the straw I created. Do you think I should dig around them and do this? 🤔

  4. Debbie M

    This is so exciting! I had no idea this was a thing! It’s a bit late for this year but now I have time to decide where it should go and what should go in it. I cannot wait until next spring!

  5. Kathlene K

    I’m looking for info about planting broccoli rabe/rapini in my SBG, without success. I’m wondering whether I can just treat it like regular broccoli. Thought?

  6. Deonna

    Thanks for such a details how in the arena of straw bale gardening. In AZ it’s time for fall gardens, but the ground is hard and full of clay. I’m reenergized to find some straw bales and get planting. My partner will be quite happy they won’t have to pick axe anymore soil. Thanks again. And happy gardening everyone.

    • Lisa Row

      Thank you Deonna!

  7. Kyle Icke

    Thank you for the info. I have been planning my garden all day and can’t wait to start!

  1. Sympathink >
  2. Straw Bale Gardening Guide >
  3. Planting & growing

Gear Guides & Reviews

Best Air Fryer

Best Angle Grinder

Best Bench Vise

Best Broadcast Spreader

Best Brush Cutter

Best Center Channel Speaker

Best Clothes Steamer

Best Corded Drill

Best Corded Electric Lawn Mower

Best Cordless Leaf Blower

Best Dethatcher

Best Digital Caliper

Best Double Din Head Unit

Best Drill

Best Dump Cart For Lawn Tractor

Best Electric Hand Planer

Best Electric Smoker

Best Garage Door Opener

Best Garden Cart

Best Garden Hose

Best Garden Seeder

Best Grill

Best Heat Gun

Best Hose Reel Cart

Best Jigsaw

Best Jointer

Best Lawn Aerator

Best Lawn Edger

Best Lawn Mower

Best Lawn Mower Lift

Best Leaf Blower

Best Manual Pole Saw

Best Planer

Best Plug Aerator

Best Pressure Washer

Best Rear Tine Tiller

Best Sander

Best Sewing Machine

Best Single Din Head Unit

Best Smoker

Best Space Heater

Best String Trimmer

Best Tile Cutter

Best Tiller

Best Tow Behind Sprayer

Best Tow Behind Spreader

Best Trolling Motor

Best Walk Behind String Trimmer

Best Weber Grill

Best Weed Eater

Best Wireless Driveway Alarm

Best Wood Chipper Shredder

Best Wood Router

Learn a New Skill